When you find yourself caught in the endless loop of repetitive thoughts, replaying scenarios, or anxiously predicting worst-case outcomes, it can feel like a frustrating and overwhelming cycle. This mental habit, known as rumination, often gets a bad rap for its draining effects on emotional well-being.
But from the lens of Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy, rumination may not be the enemy we perceive it to be. Instead, it can be understood as a protective mechanism rooted in attachment trauma.
What Is Rumination?
Rumination involves persistent and repetitive thinking, often focused on distressing emotions or events. Unlike problem-solving or reflective thinking, rumination keeps us stuck, magnifying our pain rather than alleviating it. While it’s commonly associated with anxiety and depression, rumination can also serve an adaptive purpose—at least initially—as the mind’s attempt to protect us from deeper vulnerabilities.
Attachment Trauma and Internal Parts
Attachment trauma occurs when early relationships with caregivers were marked by inconsistency, neglect, rejection, or other forms of emotional wounding. These experiences can fragment the psyche into “parts” that adopt specific roles to help us survive. In IFS therapy, these parts are often categorized as Exiles, Managers, and Firefighters:
Exiles: Parts burdened with pain, shame, or fear from the original trauma. They often feel unlovable, abandoned, or unworthy.
Managers: Parts that work proactively to prevent the Exiles’ pain from surfacing by enforcing control, perfectionism, or vigilance.
Firefighters: Parts that reactively step in to suppress Exiles’ pain, often through distractions or self-soothing behaviors.
Rumination frequently aligns with the role of a Manager. Its repetitive nature aims to keep us preoccupied, steering us away from the raw emotional wounds carried by our Exiles.
Rumination as Protection
From an IFS perspective, the act of rumination is not random or purposeless. It’s a strategy employed by parts of us that genuinely believe they are keeping us safe. For instance:
A ruminative part might think, “If I keep replaying this argument, I can prevent it from happening again.”
Another part might say, “If I anticipate rejection, I won’t be caught off guard and hurt like I was before.”
These parts are often hyper-focused on control, believing that by staying vigilant, they can prevent future harm. This is especially true for individuals with attachment trauma, where early relationships taught them that safety and connection were unpredictable or conditional. Rumination becomes a way to mentally “fix” or “prepare for” relational threats—even if it ultimately creates more distress.
Befriending the Ruminative Part
In IFS therapy, healing begins not by battling or suppressing our parts but by getting curious about them. Here are some steps to approach a ruminative part:
Notice the Part: Recognize when you’re caught in rumination. Try to separate yourself from the experience by saying, “A part of me is ruminating,” rather than “I am ruminating.”
Get Curious: Ask the ruminative part questions like:
What are you trying to protect me from?
What are you afraid would happen if you stopped?
Acknowledge Its Intentions: Even if its methods are unhelpful, the ruminative part’s intentions are likely protective. Thank it for trying to keep you safe.
Connect with the Exile: With compassion and patience, explore the vulnerable feelings or memories the rumination might be shielding. This could be a fear of abandonment, rejection, or inadequacy rooted in past experiences.
Invite Self-Leadership: Through this process, you can cultivate your core Self—the calm, compassionate, and curious center of your being—to take the lead. When the ruminative part trusts that Self can handle the pain it’s been protecting you from, it may begin to relax its grip.
Moving Toward Healing
Healing from attachment trauma involves creating a sense of safety and connection within yourself. By understanding rumination as a protective mechanism rather than a personal failing, you can approach it with compassion and curiosity. This shift in perspective can pave the way for deeper healing, as your parts begin to trust that you—your Self—are capable of handling life’s challenges.
Rather than trying to eliminate rumination, IFS invites you to embrace it as a messenger. In doing so, you’ll uncover the unmet needs and unresolved wounds it’s been trying to address. With time and inner work, the cycle of rumination can transform from a source of suffering into a doorway for growth, connection, and self-compassion.
Interested in exploring IFS and healing your attachment trauma? Contact me today!
For more information on trauma therapy, check out the link.
Comments